LIFE ... REPLACED BY FRESH CORPSE
Thomson's “Have You Seen...” Reviewed
A noir report of “Have You Seen…?”: A Personal Introduction to 1,000 Films by David Thomson (Alfred Knopf, 2008) from Noir City Sentinel, Summer 2010.
“The suspense is tender, mocking, ironic, the violence is performed, and the outbursts of passion are like phrases of music, nearly.” With these line on The Woman in the Window (1944), David Thomson leaps into the world of film noir in his colossal “Have you seen…?”: A Personal Introduction to 1,000 Films. Though he doesn’t enjoy using the term “noir” regularly, he relies on the themes that stake out the territory.
Thomson resuscitates noir’s elusive moments by depicting shots, moods, sequences, seductions — even smells. (“You can smell the sweat, the greasepaint, and the cheap perfume” in Quai des Orfevres (1947), or in The Killing (1956), “You smell Marie Windsor’s lipstick and Elisha Cook’s flop sweat.”) In his notes on William Wyler’s The Letter (1940), Thomson alludes to the theme which can open the main door to the world of noir nightmares and doubts: “desire(s) can wreck every civilized system,” and later, he suggests “we should recognize at the outset that this is chiefly because [it's] a medium that releases pent-up or taboo longings. Nowhere has it been more persuasive or insidious than in affecting out attitudes to crime and love.”